Sunday, October 13, 2013

Olivia Thaler Reaction #9


Part 3 of the novel has been my favorite section so far. All of the questions that the plot has developed throughout the first two parts have been answered, and now the author just left me with anticipation as to what could happen next. The idea of “Atlantis” was extremely eye-opening for me. I believe that Atlantis can be directly compared to the Hidden Valley, where all the superheroes (or great minds) go because the world has taken advantage of them. Through this comparison, it is easy to think that these superheroes are being selfish for their own advantage, but rather their selfishness is just an example of the clarity that makes them so superior to the outside world. In this utopia, the men and women only depend on each other as much as they depend on the other. They respect each other more because they are not out to get each other. It is an equal playing field, where no jobs are menial or lousy. They make clear that everyone has a purpose and there is no such thing as a lousy job. If American’s had this outlook on their society, our world would function much better. I found it captivating when Dagny asked Galt for a job as a cleaning lady for his house. She looked at her pay just as a teenage waitress would as she received her first paycheck. I think Rand used this instance to show that it is essential for people to start from the bottom in order to understand their influence at the top. Rand is also noting that earning money is a feat no matter how much you are getting. The problem with the outside world is just that- they take these aspects for granted.
When all of the great minds that had disappeared sat around to eat, I pictured something like Jesus sitting with his disciples at the last supper. I feel that Galt is a Christ-like figure in that manner. He wishes to change society through his teachings just like Jesus did. Galt has a God-like clarity within him, which is why he is such an influential figure. He is clearly the leader of the pack, in my opinion. It is easy to think that Galt is a selfish man, but I think he believes that the only way to fix the world is to let it self-erupt. His “disciples” seem to have a clearer outlook on life than the average person, which is why it is so easy for them to function in a society together.

1 comment:

  1. I agree with Olivia. Part 3 of this novel has also been the most captivating for me. Atlantis, in historical context, was a place that sunk so to never be found. In a way, the place where all the intellectuals live is that same city of Atlantis. It has sunken beneath radar, underneath the mountains it hides in, and only exists when a person is able to see it, which only occurs when they are brought to live there. This city of Atlantis is a place where the inhabitants are able to express themselves knowing that everyone around them accepts them.
    One thing I find very interesting is how they mention there are no small jobs. Every job is just as important as the next and this is why the secretive society is able to prosper. This cannot occur in the outside world, like Olivia states, because they take different principles into account. A society will never be able to live like the people of Atlantis, the lost city, because it takes a certain type of person, one who understands the human being, to survive.

    ReplyDelete