Sunday, October 6, 2013

Alex Williams comment on Hernan's post


 I think Hernan has an interesting perspective. I also feel that the story could have more than one or ambiguous heroes. Rand definitely prefers some characters over others, but I think it is up to the reader to decide who the protagonist is. For most of the book, I too thought that either Dagny or Hank were the primary protagonists. However now that Rand has revealed John Galt, I see that he is going to play a crucial role in the chapters ahead. I have also thought of Franciso as one of the main protagonists. He seems to be everywhere and omniscient throughout this story.
I agree that these characters are definitely protagonists, but not necessarily heroes. Rand made the point at Rearden’s trial that Rearden does more for the public good than do any of the looters. However, as Atlantis was introduced, it occurred to me that none of these retirees are doing anything to help those outside of their community. I don’t see anything wrong with this as the looters forced them into it, but I don’t think the book should imply that they are all helping the public good by working for themselves. 

No comments:

Post a Comment